CW Seed Launches Without Captioning!

This past week, a new online-only network was launched by the CW, a traditional broadcast network. The new online-only network is called CW Seed. It launched on Thursday, August 15, 2013 at cwseed.com with no closed captioning!

The CW Seed launch has received much publicity:

NY Daily News: http://www.nydailynews.com/entertainment/online-only-traditional-tv-doesn-matter-anymore-husbands-producer-article-1.1427962
LA Times: http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/envelope/cotown/la-et-ct-cw-launches-digital-cw-seed-20130815,0,901999.story
Tubefilter: http://www.tubefilter.com/2013/08/16/cw-seed-studio-husbands/
Hollywood Reporter: http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/cws-pet-squad-files-milo-606556

But how much publicity they got is not why this is important! According to that NY Daily News article linked above:

"If everyone watched on the Internet, that model would be dismantled.

That’s one reason broadcast networks are looking to get into the online distribution game themselves."


The new CW Seed is airing the third season of a popular web tv show, Husbands. This show was captioned on YouTube but now the third season is exclusive to CW Seed. With no captions. This is not the only show on CW Seed, but is an example of why it is so important now to speak up and demand captions!

The video player being used at CW Seed does not appear to support closed captioning. There is no visible CC button or option to turn on subtitles. When you right-click, this "about" information pops up:

So it appears they are using a customized Adobe Flash Player provided by a company called Digitalsmiths. At http://www.vidcompare.com/video-provider-detail.php?id=76 it does not say that their video player supports closed captioning, but it does say that their video player has subtitles capability.

This could be the first of a wave of new online only networks launched by parent traditional TV broadcasters. It is IMPORTANT to speak out NOW to prevent them from launching without including closed captioning in their planning.  We MUST make an example of the CW Seed network and force them to add closed captioning. Tweet @cwseed OR post/message facebook.com/cwseed !!!

This is proof of why we need that 21st Century Communications and Video Accessibility Act UPDATED to require professional online tv efforts to have closed captioning!

Join Caption Action 2

Join Caption Action 2 on Facebook!

Yahoo Starts Captioning! But...

Earlier today, a discovery was made: After at least five years, Yahoo has finally started to closed caption. There was no announcement from Yahoo; apparently they just started quietly. The word was put out on Twitter. People checked things out and found that Yahoo is probably using a form of automatic captioning because they noticed a lack of semantic structure and difficulty in reading the captions. One viewer pointed out that he could not see the full captioning unless viewing in full screen mode. The captions also are plain white with no background and can not be customized by viewers. So things are not perfect but it is a start.

All of Yahoo's Originals at http://screen.yahoo.com/yahoo-originals/ were checked for captioning. The total captioned is currently 16 shows out of 59. It looks like Yahoo is starting with its most popular shows and expanding.We will be adding these 16 shows to the Captioned Web TV blog accompanied by a warning note about the automatic captioning.

Join Caption Action 2

Join Caption Action 2 on Facebook!

Captioned Veronica Mars Kickstarter Pitch Video

After weeks of tweeting and asking, a volunteer stepped forward and captioned / subtitled the Veronica Mars pitch video. This video can be seen on the volunteer's YouTube page at http://youtu.be/SWcmJwanKyA . Below are "before" and "after" screenshots showing autocaptioning versus the captioned version.

It was the first time the volunteer had ever done this, and it took her fifteen tries before success. So the captions aren't perfect, but they make the video understandable. The timing of the before/after screenshots don't match exactly, but it is obvious what a difference edited captions make.  Click on the small pictures to see the bigger pictures.

Direct link to Veronica Mars Kickstarter Project (14 days left): http://kck.st/Z1HJRR

Autocaption: you're eased content-type	Edited: Ryan (Ryan laughing) No way! (Kristen enters) (cartoon type music continues to play in the background)
Autocaption: parayam general primitive hotline will weaken the extremist	Edited: Kristen: This is how we're starting our day now? Jason: You know, as a rule? I like to start every day with a hot blonde waiting for me in the parking lot. Kristen: No reenactments.

Join Caption Action 2

Join Caption Action 2 on Facebook!

Veronica Mars Movie

Update: in the early evening of 3/25/2013, @robthomas replied to say he had missed other tweets and would look into captioning and that it was a "great idea." Now he says the digital download of the movie will be captioned, and announced that publicly, but still trying to get him to caption the pitch video too. Another update (3/26/2013), @robthomas now says he is working on getting the pitch video captioned also.

Veronica Mars was a show on television for a few years. In its afterlife, it has developed a cult following. A couple of weeks ago, the producer, Rob Thomas, launched a Kickstarter campaign to raise funds to produce a movie. Warner Brothers is covering the cost of marketing and distribution but that is all; all production funds are coming from the Kickstarter campaign.

The problem with this Kickstarter campaign which is at http://kck.st/Z1HJRR? No captions on the "pitch video" which is a video that is used by people seeking funds. PLUS there are no captions on TheWb.com episodes of Veronica Mars at http://www.thewb.com/shows/veronica-mars/. AND someone on Twitter informed us that while there is a DVD, one of the seasons is not captioned on the DVD.

Why is this so important? It is important because the Veronica Mars campaign has broken records on Kickstarter. It was the fastest ever to raise $2 million. As a result, it got oodles of publicity in the media. Hearing people are tweeting up a storm about Veronica Mars and continuing to donate. It is probably very active on Facebook too.

The success of the Veronica Mars campaign is inspiring more to follow in its footsteps. In fact, the sites Kickstarter and Indiegogo are now playing a major role in the funding of various video projects, whether web television shows or regular films. Therefore, these campaigns represent one of the best opportunities we have to change attitudes about closed captioning.

If we can get them to closed caption their pitch videos, they will be more amenable to captioning the actual video/film projects. (Please note the Veronica Mars movie will be available digitally as well as in limited theatrical release.)  The idea is that if we can convince them to caption while still "pregnant," before they have even picked up a camera, we have a better likelihood of the project being captioned when it is "born."

So if you are on twitter, send a message to @robthomas and @imkristenbell asking for captions on the Veronica Mars pitch video. We have been tweeting ourselves, but the producer is not responding, perhaps because it is only one of us doing the tweeting. We need for more of you to do the tweeting or Facebooking. (Remember, in numbers, there is strength.) There's only 18 days left, but it is not too late. If you are not on twitter, you can also contact the producer via Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/VeronicaMars.

Join Caption Action 2

Join Caption Action 2 on Facebook!

Caption Action 2: March 2013 Newsletter

This is the Caption Action 2 newsletter for March 2013.

First, a final quick reminder: THIS month is a very important milestone for internet captioning law. By the end of this month - on March 30, 2013 - live and near-live video programming must be captioned online if it is shown on regular TV.

More Award Shows!

This month there are two key web series festivals: the Los Angeles Web Series Festival, and the Hollyweb festival. The Los Angeles festival is screening over 200 web series. Checking out the selected web series for both and reaching out to the producers to ask for closed captions. Some have already responded positively to say they will caption, while others have said they are already working on it.

Caption Yahoo Update

The petition asking Yahoo to update its video player to support closed captioning, has grown even more thanks to you. It is now almost 2,700! Unfortunately, there has been no response from Yahoo despite tweeting the Yahoo CEO and Yahoo Screen. Not only that, right after we sent out the February newsletter, Yahoo unveiled a new home page design. A total revamp like that costs $$, yet Yahoo did nothing to upgrade its video player to support closed captioning. It is clear where their priorities lie - and deaf and hard of hearing people aren't a priority!

http://tinyurl.com/captionyahoo

Read more: http://www.causes.com/actions/1739481-caption-action-2-march-2013-newsletter

Join Caption Action 2

Join Caption Action 2 on Facebook!

Caption Action 2: February 2013 Newsletter

This is the Caption Action 2 newsletter for February 2013.

First, a quick reminder: Next month is a very important milestone for internet captioning law. By March 30, 2013, live and near-live video programming must be captioned online if it is shown on regular TV. The exact language from the Federal Communications Commission consumer guide (http://www.fcc.gov/document/captioning-internet-video-programming-consumer-guide) is reproduced below:

Live and near-live video programming must be captioned on the Internet if it is shown on TV with captions on or after March 30, 2013. Near-live video programming is defined as programming that is performed and recorded less than 24 hours before being shown on TV for the first time.

An example of this type of programming is Dateline NBC. Dateline NBC is partially live, and the captioning is done live on regular television.

Read more: http://www.causes.com/actions/1733596-caption-action-2-february-2013-newsletter

Join Caption Action 2

Join Caption Action 2 on Facebook!